Attention: Mining Mayhem has begun!
2 months ago
Silvershadow
The Boneweaver
They/it/she
335
335 Achievements
Forum Rank 4
Forum Threads: 127
Forum Comments: 1133
General Rank 5
Starter Rank 1
Arena Rank 3
Campaign Rank 3
Gauntlet Rank 1
Cooking Rank 4
Crafting Rank 5
Farming Rank 3
Fishing Rank 3
Hunting Rank 3
Mining Rank 3
Looking for information on the economy (ms:pb ratio over the years)

I had a stupid idea that I really wanna do. I want to make a GRAPH! For the moonstone:pebble ratio since LW was first created or whatnot.

First while before I joined (idk what year LW started):
2023ish: 1:25k
2024ish: 1:38k?
2025: i was gone all last year and some of 2024 i think, so I need help
2026: 1:101k

More specific data, like per month, would also be nice if anyone remembers.
I need information from [year lw started] through mid-late 2023, then from late 2024 through early-mid 2026
Thank you!

(Edited)
Report

I want more pineapples

Someday I'll get around to adding art down here, yup mmhm totally 1000% gonna happen

2 months ago
Veradana
319
319 Achievements
Forum Rank 1
Forum Threads: 26
Forum Comments: 81
General Rank 5
Starter Rank 1
Arena Rank 4
Campaign Rank 4
Cooking Rank 5
Crafting Rank 5
Farming Rank 1
Fishing Rank 3
Hunting Rank 2
Mining Rank 4
I'm not even sure how accurate a ratio would be because you may have people selling pebbles for moonstones, but good luck finding people selling moonstones for pebbles.
Report
Quote
2 months ago
Silvershadow
The Boneweaver
They/it/she
335
335 Achievements
Forum Rank 4
Forum Threads: 127
Forum Comments: 1133
General Rank 5
Starter Rank 1
Arena Rank 3
Campaign Rank 3
Gauntlet Rank 1
Cooking Rank 4
Crafting Rank 5
Farming Rank 3
Fishing Rank 3
Hunting Rank 3
Mining Rank 3
@Veradana
I'm awful at words- I meant people selling pebbles for ms. For instance back when I joined I could buy 25k pebbles for 1 moonstone aaand nowadays it's four times that much
What I'm curious about is what happened in between those two times and before I joined. Sorry again about the confusion, I truly am horrible at wording things cohesively-
Report
Quote

I want more pineapples

Someday I'll get around to adding art down here, yup mmhm totally 1000% gonna happen

2 months ago
XDragonfruitx
The Wanderer
Whatever
366
366 Achievements
Forum Rank 4
Forum Threads: 111
Forum Comments: 1529
General Rank 5
Starter Rank 1
Arena Rank 5
Campaign Rank 4
Cooking Rank 4
Crafting Rank 4
Farming Rank 4
Fishing Rank 3
Hunting Rank 3
Mining Rank 3
More people acquired more Pebbles and so were willing to shell out more for a Moonstone. The ratio has been 100kp:1MS for at least a year mlnow with some fluctuations. I suspect it will jump again once the newer players have more Pebbles to their name. I know some players were pushing for 10kp:1MS and I did manage to get some at that rate back in the day.
(Edited)
Report
Quote

Have a blue and orange wolf? I might buy it!

Buying G2 Bracchus. DM me : Pageant Pals Discussion

2 months ago
Reave
The Tenacious
¯\_ (ツ)_/¯
378
378 Achievements
Forum Rank 3
Forum Threads: 16
Forum Comments: 592
General Rank 5
Starter Rank 1
Arena Rank 4
Campaign Rank 5
Gauntlet Rank 1
Cooking Rank 4
Crafting Rank 4
Farming Rank 3
Fishing Rank 3
Hunting Rank 3
Mining Rank 5
There's some interesting "shenanigans" surrounding the ms:FR gem market that I've been keeping an eye on, gaming both sites in a way that is beneficial if the p:ms ratio stays stagnant like it has for so long despite the continued pebble inflation. People get very defensive about that topic, though! Last time I mentioned it I wasn't careful enough with my phrasing, so hopefully this is good enough. ;)

That's ultimately just a quibble contributing to the fact that far fewer people are interested in pebble -- moonstone trades though, since pebbles are quite literally worthless / have no recurring sinks or uses, and that's been made worse with Guilds offering discounts on the problem areas & what tiny minor sinks did exist in the professions, without offering any real sinks in return, lol. Blows MY mind, but ok, it's just the material reality of the game that this exists & contributes to the problem.

I've been sitting north of a hundred million pebbles for a WHILE and that's with trying to get rid of them millions at a time. There are tons of players sitting on even more because they are still actively engaging with pebble farming instead of continually buying random MM food/crafting items to offload them. There's just nothing "really" worth buying, so the only sink I've been finding is dumping them on new players so they can get their upgrades unlocked.

The only good side of this is that MS has become easier to unlock for new players too, mostly through finite Achievements but also through guilds to some degree, so they can get their den unlocks without as much hassle. I'm still sitting on thousands of MS that ultimately has no use for me either since I don't care about CA, but at least those have some theoretical uses / recurring purchasing power for those that do care about and like CA.

Ultimately, tho, the ratio over the years didn't grow gradually, it didn't really have the chance to. It kinda started in fits and jumps, from 10kp:1ms to 25kp:1ms pretty shortly after, to 50kp:1ms (which was where it was at the last time I bought ms with pebbles) and it kinda hung in the 56-60kp area for a little bit, to now it's been 100kp:1ms and has been for a whiiillee. You don't really see ms listed on the FM much, when I have seen it in the past year it's been 160kp+. Some people are willing to pay that upcharge I suppose, but I've just been ignoring it since then.
(Edited)
Report
Quote

"Once again I have to bear the burden of having every correct opinion in the world."

2 months ago
Silvershadow
The Boneweaver
They/it/she
335
335 Achievements
Forum Rank 4
Forum Threads: 127
Forum Comments: 1133
General Rank 5
Starter Rank 1
Arena Rank 3
Campaign Rank 3
Gauntlet Rank 1
Cooking Rank 4
Crafting Rank 5
Farming Rank 3
Fishing Rank 3
Hunting Rank 3
Mining Rank 3
Oh my that's- lotsa words hold on this might take me a couple centuries
uhm 100 million pebbles. I am still at just over 3 million and that's from me having to constantly restock from the fm-
how do people get so many pebbles?? I know my question is now diverging from my original question but in my defense it is late at night and I am far too tired to make a statement that somewhat makes sense
(Edited)
Report
Quote

I want more pineapples

Someday I'll get around to adding art down here, yup mmhm totally 1000% gonna happen

2 months ago
lalierre
The Pickiest
She/her
502
502 Achievements
Forum Rank 4
Forum Threads: 60
Forum Comments: 1118
General Rank 5
Starter Rank 1
Arena Rank 5
Campaign Rank 5
Gauntlet Rank 5
Cooking Rank 5
Crafting Rank 5
Farming Rank 5
Fishing Rank 5
Hunting Rank 5
Mining Rank 5
If memory serves correctly I would say the 100kp rate has been consistent for at least a year and half at this point. Even though my guess is the “true” rate should maybe go up a little bit more (maybe 120k, or 150k long term?) it seems to have remained fairly steady with only minor fluctuations.

The rate on the other side has been wild over time — people selling moonstones for pebbles. It was upward of 200k or more for a while back in spring 2025 and I started actively listing to bring that price down closer to the pebble-side price, landing eventually at 120k. I stopped listing when an influx of returning players started buying up all my MS immediately no matter the quantity and moved to a trade thread so everyone can have an opportunity at purchasing moonstones. I think it’s listed at 100k currently? But I stick to whatever the pebble-side rate is — I’m mostly just trying to offer MS with a focus on accessibility and removing arbitrage opportunities.
Report
Quote
2 months ago
Veradana
319
319 Achievements
Forum Rank 1
Forum Threads: 26
Forum Comments: 81
General Rank 5
Starter Rank 1
Arena Rank 4
Campaign Rank 4
Cooking Rank 5
Crafting Rank 5
Farming Rank 1
Fishing Rank 3
Hunting Rank 2
Mining Rank 4
Oh my that's- lotsa words hold on this might take me a couple centuries
uhm 100 million pebbles. I am still at just over 3 million and that's from me having to constantly restock from the fm-
how do people get so many pebbles?? I know my question is now diverging from my original question but in my defense it is late at night and I am far too tired to make a statement that somewhat makes sense
Pebble generating companions. Every wolf in my den has one with a 6-hour cooldown (except for two who have 4 hour cooldowns but I was using them in guild boss battles for their poison attack). Every 6 hours with a click of a single button (Nana) I can generate nearly 100'000 pebbles, and I'm not even maxed out on the number of wolves I can have. Someone who has could make over 500'000 pebbles every 6 hours with zero effort beyond having to have gotten so many companions.
Report
Quote
2 months ago
Silvershadow
The Boneweaver
They/it/she
335
335 Achievements
Forum Rank 4
Forum Threads: 127
Forum Comments: 1133
General Rank 5
Starter Rank 1
Arena Rank 3
Campaign Rank 3
Gauntlet Rank 1
Cooking Rank 4
Crafting Rank 5
Farming Rank 3
Fishing Rank 3
Hunting Rank 3
Mining Rank 3
holy sheshkabobs no wonder I always get so many pebbles from my phoenixes even when I've already played all my kapuras n stuff
New thing to try for, then. Thank you!
Report
Quote

I want more pineapples

Someday I'll get around to adding art down here, yup mmhm totally 1000% gonna happen

Unsubscribe from Post
Subscribe to Thread
Recent
Subscribed
My posts
Recent Activity
1 2 3 4 5 ... 10
Subscribed
You are not subscribed to any threads.
My Threads
You do not have any threads.
Trees
Music
Shuffle
Theme
Enable to have Music selection based site activities.
Repeat
Enable to repeat the current song.
Volume
Dismiss
Not interested in music? Permanently dismiss this music player.
Afternoon Stroll
Bathing on an Arturas
Boil 'em, Mash 'em
Canictonis Crossing
Dreaming About You
Embarking
Fields of Loria
First Snow
Follow the Leader
Good Morning, Challengers
Haunted Cave
Head in the Clouds
Into the Deep
Keep Going
Lone Wolf
Lost Music Box
Moonsblessings
Mosey Through the Forums
Nothing but Time
Play Date With Nana
Queueing Up
Sanity Check
Silly Walk
Sleepy Wolves
Sploosh
Sunken Melody
The Mighty Remain
Through Goldsea
Trailing Behind
What to Buy?